The Best Safeties in the NFL: An In-Depth Analysis for 2025
As the NFL training camps for 2025 approach, league experts have shared their opinions. Alofoke Deportes presents a detailed analysis of the top 10 players at the safety position, based on surveys of NFL executives, coaches, and scouts. This is the sixth edition of these rankings, and as usual, some players have moved up or down compared to the lists from the previous year. The ranking process involved votes from experts, composite averages, and in-depth interviews, with the help of the NFL analyst from Alofoke Deportes. The main objective is to identify the best players of the moment, without long-term projections or career achievement awards. Who are the best players today? The analysis focuses on versatility, a crucial aspect in the modern safety position, which has become a combination of different roles. Current safeties must be able to perform in various positions and adapt to team strategies.
Kevin Sabitus/Getty Images
The list of the NFL’s top 10 safeties is based on votes from league executives, coaches, and scouts.- Kyle Hamilton, Baltimore Ravens: Benefits from confidence despite a slight decrease in production. An NFL personnel director describes him as the “best all-around player.”
- Brian Branch, Detroit Lions: Proved his worth with four interceptions and 16 pass deflections. An AFC executive highlights his instinct and versatility.
- Xavier McKinney, Green Bay Packers: Signed a $68 million contract and validated the trust placed in him with eight interceptions. An NFL personnel evaluator praises his multiple skills and intelligence on the field.
- Jessie Bates III, Atlanta Falcons: An example of success in free agency, with 10 interceptions and 21 pass deflections for the Falcons. An AFC executive highlights his improvement in tackling.
- Kerby Joseph, Detroit Lions: Rose to the top 5 after signing an $86 million contract extension. Stands out for his ability to generate turnovers.
- Derwin James Jr., Los Angeles Chargers: Returned to his best form after overcoming injuries, showing his impact on the game.
- Antoine Winfield Jr., Tampa Bay Buccaneers: Had a season with less impact due to injuries, but is still considered an elite player.
- Budda Baker, Arizona Cardinals: Despite his age, he remains a standout player on the line of scrimmage.
- Minkah Fitzpatrick, Miami Dolphins: Returned to the team that drafted him, seeking to regain his best level.
- Julian Love, Seattle Seahawks: Has had a significant impact in Seattle, accumulating interceptions and tackles.
The following players also received votes:
- Jevon Holland, New York Giants
- Brandon Jones, Denver Broncos
- C.J. Gardner-Johnson, Houston Texans
- Tre’von Moehrig, Carolina Panthers
- Calen Bullock, Houston Texans
- Justin Reid, New Orleans Saints
- Jalen Pitre, Houston Texans
- Kyle Dugger, New England Patriots
- Talanoa Hufanga, Denver Broncos
- Harrison Smith, Minnesota Vikings
- Grant Delpit, Cleveland Browns
- Quentin Lake, Los Angeles Rams
