The Impact of the Game on Sport: A Recount of Controversies
On May 14, 2018, the United States Supreme Court overturned the Professional and Amateur Sports Protection Act of 1992, allowing the legalization of sports betting outside of Nevada, where it had been primarily permitted for 26 years. This decision marked a turning point, opening a multi-million dollar market and generating new dynamics in the world of sports. Since then, 39 states, the District of Columbia, and Puerto Rico have legalized sports betting, with bettors already having invested more than $330 billion in state-licensed sportsbooks. However, the rise in betting has brought with it an increase in controversies. In the last two years, dozens of professional and college athletes and coaches have been suspended or fired for game-related violations. In early 2024, investigations were launched into suspicious betting in Temple men’s basketball and prop bets involving Toronto Raptors player Jontay Porter. The NBA banned Porter for life after its investigation revealed that he had disclosed confidential information to bettors, limited his participation in at least one game, and bet on G League games. The gaming industry and sports leagues claim that the legal system is working, as the greater visibility of betting helps detect anomalies. However, incidents, including players betting on games in which they participate, persist. Parallel to this, the market for clandestine betting, which has existed in the United States since sports have, continues to thrive. Unlicensed operators offer credit and attract high-profile clients seeking anonymity. Ippei Mizuhara, former interpreter for Los Angeles Dodgers superstar Shohei Ohtani, was fired in March for using a bookmaker. Mizuhara surrendered to authorities after prosecutors alleged he stole more than $16 million from Ohtani’s account. California and Texas, the two largest states, have not yet legalized sports betting, so the US market has a lot of room to grow. The uncertainty about the final size of the market is great, but the certainty that there will be more controversies is high.
Timeline of Incidents Related to Sports Betting
2018
May 14, 2018: The Supreme Court strikes down federal prohibitions on sports betting. The United States Supreme Court struck down the Professional and Amateur Sports Protection Act of 1992, a law that prohibited state-authorized sports betting (Nevada was primarily the only exception). The ruling opened the door for any state interested in legalizing sports betting to do so.2019
November 29, 2019: The NFL indefinitely suspends Josh Shaw. Josh Shaw was the first active player, though on the injured list, to be suspended for betting on league games. He openly bet at a Las Vegas sportsbook against his own team at the time, the Arizona Cardinals, as part of a parlay bet.
2020
September 8, 2020: The University of Colorado signs a sponsorship agreement with PointsBet. The five-year agreement between Colorado and PointsBet allowed the sports betting operator to display signs at Colorado’s football stadium and basketball pavilion, as well as have advertisements in other media such as radio broadcasts.2021
May 26, 2021: The Capital One Arena in Washington becomes the first professional sports stadium in the U.S. with a fully operational sportsbook. Monumental Sports, owner of the Washington Wizards, Washington Mystics, and Washington Capitals, agreed to a 10-year lease with William Hill Sportsbook.October 8, 2021: Felipe Hernandez of Sporting KC is suspended for betting on MLS matches. An independent investigation launched in July 2021 found that Hernandez had participated in “extensive and illegal sports betting” while a member of Sporting Kansas City, including bets on MLS matches. Hernandez had informed the team about his bets on July 5, telling them that he was concerned for his personal safety due to the debts he had accumulated.2022
March 7, 2022: The NFL suspends Calvin Ridley for one year.Ridley, receiver for the Atlanta Falcons at the time, was suspended for at least the entire 2022 season after the NFL determined that he had bet on games during a five-day period in November 2021 while on the non-football injury list. Sources reported that the period included combined bets that included the Falcons to win. He was reinstated in March 2023.
Contents

2023
January 19, 2023: UFC tightens rules on betting and hires an integrity company. The UFC added stricter language on betting to its combat conduct code and hired U.S. Integrity, a sports betting monitoring company. The change was due to suspicious betting patterns related to a UFC fight between Darrick Minner and Shayilan Nuerdanbieke.March 29, 2023: The University of Colorado and PointsBet end their partnership three years early. Colorado and SportsBet announced in a joint statement that it was “mutually beneficial” to end their partnership after almost three years. A day earlier, the American Gaming Association had published revised guidelines that discouraged similar partnerships between betting houses and universities.April 21, 2023: Jameson Williams among five NFL players suspended for gambling. Detroit Lions wide receiver Quintez Cephus, safety C.J. Moore, and Washington Commanders defensive end Shaka Toney were suspended indefinitely for betting on NFL games, while Jameson Williams and Stanley Berryhill were suspended for six games for mobile bets that occurred at the Lions’ Allen Park facility, although Williams and Berryhill did not bet on NFL games.May 4, 2023: Alabama fires baseball coach Brad Bohannon after link to suspicious betting. Ohio’s gambling regulators initially halted betting on college baseball games involving Alabama after suspicious betting activity was detected for their game against LSU. Federal prosecutors alleged that Bert Neff, an Indiana businessman and youth baseball coach, contacted Bohannon before a baseball game between Alabama and LSU and proceeded to bet against the Crimson Tide. Alabama fired Bohannon six days after the betting was stopped.May 8, 2023: Investigation into gambling at Iowa-Iowa State begins. The University of Iowa and Iowa State University announce that more than three dozen athletes, spanning baseball, American football, men’s basketball, men’s track and field, and wrestling, and a full-time employee of Iowa’s athletic department, were suspected of violating NCAA rules against sports betting.June 29, 2023: The NFL suspends four players for gambling violations. Isaiah Rodgers Sr. and Rashod Berry of the Indianapolis Colts and free agent Demetrius Taylor were suspended by the NFL at least through the 2023 season for betting on NFL games in 2022. Rodgers, however, said the bets he made were for other people, whom he refused to identify.September 29, 2023: Jameson Williams is reinstated after the NFL modifies the gambling policy. The NFL modified its gambling policies so that players who bet on their own teams would be punished more severely, a suspension of at least two years, and players who bet on any NFL game would be punished with a one-year suspension. Players who bet on non-NFL sports while on team premises or on team-related trips would now receive a two-game suspension for a first violation, six games for a second, and at least a year for a third.October 26, 2023: Shane Pinto, NHL player, is suspended for 41 games for gambling. It’s not clear how Shane Pinto, center for the Ottawa Senators, violated the NHL’s sports betting policy, but Pinto had an online betting account in the U.S. that was flagged by an NHL integrity protection partner “due to unusual activity,” according to the Ottawa Sun.October 27, 2023: Two Korn Ferry Tour golfers are suspended for sports betting. Vince India and Jake Staiano, golfers on the PGA Tour developmental circuit, were suspended for three and six months, respectively, for placing bets on PGA Tour competitions. Neither bet on tournaments in which they played.