MLB Title Contenders Analysis: Who Has What It Takes?
The MLB season is heading towards an unpredictable postseason. With several teams battling and others facing key issues, the race for the World Series is more open than ever. We analyze the main contenders, evaluating their strengths and weaknesses to determine who has what it takes to reach the top.
Favorites
Milwaukee Brewers
Real or Not? The Brewers don’t hit enough home runs to win the World Series.
Years ago, Joe Morgan argued that teams should “manufacture runs in the postseason.” The Brewers, who don’t rely on home runs to generate offense, could have a problem. Recent history indicates that home runs are key to postseason success. Teams that out-hit their opponents in home runs have an impressive record in recent years.
- 2021: 25-2
- 2022: 22-6
- 2023: 25-3
- 2024: 23-8
However, if they don’t out-homerun their opponents, they still won 41% of postseason games. The key for the Brewers could be to win games where they tie their opponent in home runs.
Verdict: REAL. The Brewers could benefit from their pitchers not allowing many home runs and their hitters getting hot in October. However, recent history favors teams with power at the plate.
Los Angeles Dodgers
Real or Not? The Dodgers’ bullpen issues will prevent them from winning the World Series.
Last year, the Dodgers’ pitching problems seemed to be their Achilles’ heel. This year, the concern is the bullpen, which has dealt with injuries and ranks 19th in MLB in effectiveness. Although the relief corps is talented and is now reasonably healthy, inconsistency could be a factor.
Verdict: NOT REAL. Although any bullpen can have a good month, the Dodgers have a talented and now reasonably healthy group, with left-handed options that will give manager Dave Roberts flexibility.
Philadelphia Phillies
Real or Not? Jhoan Duran is finally the closer the Phillies needed.
The Phillies have had bullpen issues in recent postseasons. With the arrival of Jhoan Duran, they have their best closer since 2008. Duran throws 100 mph with an effective splitter, and his ability to induce ground balls and keep the ball in the park is crucial.
Verdict: REAL. Although the absence of Jose Alvarado and the injuries of Zack Wheeler and Trea Turner could affect, Duran provides great confidence for the Phillies.
Detroit Tigers
Real or Not? The Tigers have an ace in Tarik Skubal, but the lack of a second starter is a big problem.
The uncertainty about the Tigers’ second starter raises doubts. Although Tarik Skubal is an elite pitcher, the inconsistency of the options for the second starter could be detrimental. Recent history shows that the second starter is important, but not indispensable.
Verdict: NOT REAL. If Skubal dominates and the bullpen performs, the Tigers could still aim for the title.
Toronto Tiles
Real or Not? The Blue Jays’ bullpen will be their downfall.
The Blue Jays’ bullpen has been inconsistent, and manager John Schneider has made questionable decisions. The lack of offense has been a problem in the past, and the team’s ability to hit will be key.
Verdict: NOT REAL. Although the bullpen is a concern, Toronto’s offense will determine its fate.
New York Yankees
Real or Not? Aaron Judge will have to hit, and hit a lot, in the postseason for the Yankees to succeed.
Aaron Judge has been criticized for his postseason performance. Although the Yankees lead the league in home runs, they rely heavily on Judge. His performance, especially after a shoulder injury, will be crucial for the team’s aspirations.
Verdict: REAL. The Yankees need Judge to perform at his best.
Chicago Cubs
Real or Not? The depth of the Cubs’ alignment is perfect for the postseason.
The Cubs have above-average hitters in almost every position in the lineup. The depth of their offense, which resembles that of recent championship teams, could be a key advantage.
Verdict: REAL. The Cubs’ solid offense makes them serious contenders.
Possible Candidates
Boston Red Sox
Real or Not? Without Roman Anthony, you can kiss the World Series title goodbye.
Roman Anthony’s injury is a tough blow. Although his absence is significant, the team has performed better overall since July. The Red Sox have a great closer in Aroldis Chapman and bullpen depth, which could compensate for Anthony’s absence.
Verdict: NOT REAL. Anthony’s absence is a blow, but the Red Sox have the depth and talent to compete.
New York Mets
Real or Not? The Mets will have to rely on rookie starters Nolan McLean and Jonah Tong, and it could work.
The Mets’ rotation has been inconsistent, and they now rely on rookies McLean and Tong. Although history is not in their favor, the talent of these rookie pitchers and the team’s offense could surprise.
Verdict: REAL. Although history is not on their side, the Mets have the potential to compete.
San Diego Padres
Real or Not? Like the Brewers, the Padres don’t hit enough home runs to win.
The Padres’ lack of power is notable. Although they added hitters at the trade deadline, their offense might not be enough to overcome opponents in the postseason.
Verdict: REAL. The Padres will need their stars to perform at their best and their bullpen to be impeccable.
Houston Astros
Real or Not? Yordan Alvarez’s return gives the Astros the offense they need.
The return of Yordan Alvarez and other key players significantly improves the Astros’ offense. With two ace-level starters and a potentially lethal bullpen, the Astros have the ingredients needed to compete in an open American League.
Verdict: REAL. The Astros have the potential to go far.
Seattle Mariners
Real or Not? You can’t win the World Series if you can’t win on the road.
The Mariners, who have had an irregular performance away from home, need to improve their away game to succeed in the postseason. Their ability to win away from home will be crucial.
