England Favorite in the Six Nations: Overreactions? Analysis

Deep Analysis of International Rugby: Exaggerated or Justified Reactions?

The recent weekend marked the close of the international rugby season, leaving behind a collection of emotions and debates. England consolidated its winning streak, South Africa demonstrated its supremacy, and even Wales showed flashes of hope. But, how to interpret these performances? Are the reactions of the public and experts rational or exaggerated? We analyze the key points. We analyze the opinions of Tom Hamilton and James Regan on the hottest topics of the weekend.

• England: Have they forgotten how to lose?
• Tom Curry: A “thug” on the field?
• Ireland: “Chaotic” defeat and the coach’s pride.
• South Africa: Remembers the superiority against Ireland.

England achieved their eleventh consecutive victory by defeating Argentina to close out 2025.

England: Favorite for the Six Nations?

England finished the autumn with four victories, positioning them as a strong contender for the title. However, should they be considered the favorites?Verdict: Overreaction.England’s autumn performance was impeccable, achieving the goal of sweeping their opponents. The team has shown greater depth in its squad and has generated interesting dilemmas for coach Steve Borthwick. However, are they really the favorites for the Six Nations? For Hamilton, France remains the team to beat. With their recent victory over Australia, a player like Louis Bielle-Biarrey, and the incorporation of new talents, France seems to be at a higher level.

Tom Curry, A “Thug”?

Argentina was not happy with a tackle by Tom Curry on Juan Cruz Mallia.Felipe Contepomi expressed his anger at Curry’s late tackle on Juan Cruz Mallia, which resulted in a knee injury. In the post-match press conference, Contepomi called Curry a “thug” after an altercation in the tunnel.Verdict: Overreaction.Curry’s entry was late and fell into the gray area between a penalty and a yellow card. Contepomi, visibly annoyed, confronted the officials, and the tension increased at the end of the match. In the tunnel, an incident occurred where Curry, after greeting a member of Argentina’s coaching staff, was accused by Contepomi of “bully” behavior. Hamilton understands Contepomi’s frustration, but defends Curry, arguing that he is not a malicious player, but someone who plays on the edge and gives his all. Several teammates, including Henry Slade, supported this view, highlighting his genuine and committed character.

Wales: Out of the Abyss?

Nigel French/PA Images via Getty Images

Despite the defeat against New Zealand (52-26), Wales showed signs of improvement. Is this a positive sign?

Verdict: Not an Overreaction.

For 45 minutes, Wales competed with New Zealand, which, given their recent difficulties, is a positive aspect. Let’s not forget that Wales went 18 games without winning. Despite the defeat, the team showed determination and displayed an offensive game. Although New Zealand widened the gap on the scoreboard, there was optimism in the Principality Stadium, suggesting an improvement for the Six Nations.

Ireland: In a Loop?

Ireland suffered their second defeat this autumn, this time at the hands of the Springboks.After the defeat against South Africa (24-13), Ireland has won two out of four matches this autumn, which raises concerns.Verdict: Overreaction.Coach Andy Farrell was proud after the match, highlighting his team’s resilience. Ireland hasn’t become a bad team overnight, despite the results. They have suffered injuries and their bench lacked impact. While their attacking game has been inconsistent, it’s difficult to compete with South Africa at their best. With Farrell in charge, the Six Nations could be more promising.

South Africa: The Pinnacle of World Rugby

South Africa proved once again that they are the best in the world.The Springboks, although they might end the year with some losses, remain at the top of the rankings and have secured the Rugby Championship. Are they the standard to follow?

Verdict: Not an Overreaction.

The goal of South Africa this year was to secure a place in the top four of the ranking. Coach Erasmus plans to innovate next year. The Boks seek to continuously improve. They have demonstrated the emerging talent of players like Sacha Feinberg-Mngomezulu and the versatility of Andre Esterhuizen. Although they have had some setbacks, their dominance is undeniable. Their physicality and emotional aggression are benchmarks, and their squad depth is enviable. They finished the year without key players, demonstrating their strength and ability to adapt. They are expected to continue dominating, with the goal of winning and dominating the northern hemisphere.

Scott Robertson: A Pending Judgment

After three defeats this year, Scott Robertson faces a decisive 2026.The All Blacks have suffered three defeats this year, but there’s more to the story. Is it time to worry?

Verdict: Not an Overreaction.

New Zealand hasn’t found its best form this year. Despite important victories, expectations are high. Robertson is giving experience to new players, which could be crucial for the 2027 World Cup.