Crisis in the Big Apple? Analysis of the Mets and Yankees’ Fall
The 2025 MLB season promised an exciting “Subway Series” for New York fans. In mid-May, both the Mets and the Yankees were leading their respective divisions, projecting a sure presence in the postseason. However, the landscape has changed drastically for both teams. The Yankees, after losing the lead in the American League East, faced concern over the injury of their star Aaron Judge and lost ground in the wild card race. The Mets, for their part, suffered a streak of seven consecutive losses, going from competing for the lead in the National League East to clinging to the last wild card spot.Is this a simple slump for two teams with playoff aspirations or the beginning of an epic collapse? What do they need to turn things around? Which of the New York teams will go further in October? We analyze the situation with MLB experts.
Concerns and Key Factors
The Mets’ starting pitchers’ body has been a weak point. Since June 13, their starters rank last in ERA and innings pitched. Sean Manaea and Kodai Senga’s performances have not met expectations. Despite this, the Mets’ offense has the potential to improve, and teams like the Cincinnati Reds or the St. Louis Cardinals are unlikely to surpass the Mets for the third wild card spot. The National League’s strength and the Mets’ problems, including a struggling offense, an inconsistent rotation, and an inconsistent bullpen, are cause for concern. The Milwaukee Brewers and the Philadelphia Phillies set the pace in the league. The Mets have not lived up to that standard recently. While it’s true that the Mets have had flaws, their bullpen is deep and their offensive production hasn’t been the best. The team has had the worst on-base percentage among relievers since August 1st, but this will tend to improve. The Mets may not be unbeatable, but they’ve spent more time in first place this year than in other positions. The idea that everything would disappear in two weeks doesn’t do them justice. The Mets have lost ground in the division, but their good performance in the first half will allow them to be in the playoffs. The offense has had a prolonged slump and the rotation is unstable, although it has exceeded expectations.The Yankees’ Situation
The concern is high for the Yankees. Aaron Judge’s health has been key, and his injury has affected their performance. The starting rotation has not been consistent, the bullpen has failed at critical moments, and the offense has relied too much on the home run. The Yankees have the talent to compete for the World Series, but they must stop the bleeding. The team is still trying to define its bullpen, which is difficult in a championship race. However, the Yankees have a favorable schedule at the end of the season. The return of Fernando Cruz, Ryan Yarbrough, and Jonathan Loáisiga could strengthen the pitching staff. The Yankees seem to be the best option in an American League with competitive options. If the middle part of the Yankees’ lineup stays on the field, they could have a chance. They need their starters to regain their level. Max Fried and Carlos Rodon’s performance has been low in the second half.
Image by Benny Sieu-Imagn Images
