MLB Trade Deadline Analysis: Winners and Losers
The MLB trade deadline this year, although it didn’t see star player moves of the caliber of Juan Soto in 2022, nor the large number of trades of last year, culminated in a series of surprising transactions. The 6 p.m. ET deadline generated a whirlwind of activity.
Among the most impactful moves, the Astros got Carlos Correa back, while the Athletics traded closer Mason Miller to the Padres in exchange for Leo De Vries, one of the game’s most promising prospects. In addition, Shane Bieber, still in rehabilitation in the minors, moved from Cleveland to Toronto, and the Orioles and Diamondbacks were active as expected. But who were the real winners and losers of this deadline?The Big Winners
Seattle Mariners
The Mariners acquired the two best hitters available on the market, Eugenio Suárez and Josh Naylor, in two separate trades with the Diamondbacks, without parting with any of their top 10 prospects. A masterstroke by the president of baseball operations, Jerry Dipoto, who, with approval to invest more, has built one of the strongest lineups in the majors, led by the home run duo of Cal Raleigh and Suárez.
With only one playoff appearance since 2001, and having missed by one game in the last two seasons, the Mariners’ urgency to reinforce themselves was clear. Although they are still fighting for a wild card spot and chasing the Astros in the American League West Division, consistency in their rotation will be crucial.
The only criticism of Seattle’s management was the lack of an impact reliever, despite the acquisition of Caleb Ferguson from the Pirates. A high-caliber reliever to complement Andrés Muñoz would have completed an even more successful deadline.San Diego Padres
The Padres kicked off their deadline with the surprising trade of prospect Leo De Vries for A’s closer Mason Miller. Then, they added Ryan O’Hearn and Ramon Laureano from the Orioles, and catcher Freddy Fermin from the Royals. In this way, the Padres addressed their main needs: left field, designated hitter, and catcher, in addition to adding one of the best relievers in the game. With a dominant rotation, the Padres are shaping up to be a dangerous team in October, with an also improved offense.Philadelphia Phillies
With an experienced roster and a trio of starting pitchers in excellent form, the Phillies bet on the present. The acquisition of Jhoan Duran is a long-term solution for their bullpen, although it cost them two of their best prospects. In another move, they added Harrison Bader, who could be the starting center fielder.New York Mets
The Mets bolstered their bullpen with the addition of Tyler Rogers, Ryan Helsley, and Gregory Soto, solidifying a high-level relief corps. With Edwin Díaz, Reed Garrett, Ryne Stanek, and Brooks Raley already on the team, the Mets’ bullpen looks promising. The Mets’ strategy, led by David Stearns, demonstrates their ability to make bold moves.Houston Astros
The Astros added Carlos Correa for third base, Jesús Sánchez to strengthen the left-handed batting, and Ramón Urías as a utility infielder. Jeremy Peña’s return on Friday significantly improves the lineup. With an elite bullpen and a solid starting duo, the Astros seek to maintain their position in the American League West Division.Athletics
The transfer of Mason Miller for Leo De Vries was one of the boldest moves, obtaining a top-tier prospect. At 18 years old, De Vries is proving his worth, which could make him a franchise player.New York Yankees
The Yankees added Ryan McMahon, José Caballero, Amed Rosario, David Bednar, Austin Slater, Jake Bird, and Camilo Doval. Although they didn’t manage to sign Eugenio Suárez or a starting pitcher, they improved their depth and versatility.The Biggest Losers
Minnesota Twins
The Twins released nine players, including key pieces of their bullpen. While some players were about to enter free agency, the team’s strategy raised doubts about their commitment to winning. The future of the Twins seems uncertain, and rebuilding the bullpen will be a challenge.Chicago Cubs
Despite being a team competing for the National League Central Division title, the Cubs were not aggressive in the market, which could affect their aspirations.Boston Red Sox
The Red Sox added Dustin May and Steven Matz, but did not make moves that significantly altered their playoff chances.Cincinnati Reds
The Reds made some moves that don’t fit well, with signings that don’t seem like a clear improvement.Detroit Tigers
The Tigers focused on reinforcing their pitching, but failed to solve the problems in the bullpen, despite having a promising farm system.Milwaukee Brewers
The Brewers didn’t make any big moves, although they already had a solid team. The lack of a power hitter could affect their chances in the Division.
