MLB: Forgotten Stars, the Draft of the Most Unexpected All-Stars

alofoke
3 Min Read

The Most Surprising All-Star Game Selections: Unexpected Stories on the Diamond

In baseball, each season brings with it stories of overcoming, talent, and, sometimes, unexpected selections for the All-Star Game. Although each team has its representative, some choices surprise due to their uniqueness. The case of Hunter Goodman, of the Colorado Rockies, is an example. Although his season is good, the question is whether he is really among the top 32 players in the National League. However, he is now an All-Star. Throughout MLB history, almost 10% of players have been All-Stars. But, who are the most unexpected?

Frankie Zak: The Most Unexpected All-Star

In MLB history, Frankie Zak stands out as the most improbable All-Star. During World War II, when rosters were filled with minor league players, Zak, a young backup shortstop for the Pittsburgh Pirates, had his moment. With only 123 games in the majors and no home runs, Zak was selected for the 1944 All-Star Game. Despite his performance, his inclusion was more due to circumstances than his own merits.

Eddie Kazak: A War Hero at the All-Star Game

MLB: Forgotten Stars, the Draft of the Most Unexpected All-Stars
Eddie Kazak, third baseman for the St. Louis Cardinals, is another notable story. A veteran of World War II, Kazak suffered a serious elbow injury. Despite medical warnings, he managed to reach the majors and was selected for the 1949 All-Star Game, even starting. His story of courage moved the fans, who voted him over more prominent players.

An Unexpected Team of Stars

If we were to form a team of players who were starters in the All-Star Game, but who were not prominent figures, we would have a curious lineup.
  • C: John Romano (1961)
  • 1B: Justin Smoak (2017)
  • 2B: Mariano Duncan (1994)
  • 3B: Eddie Kazak (1949)
  • SS: Orlando Arcia (2023)
  • LF: Iván Calderón (1991)
  • CF: Kosuke Fukudome (2008)
  • RF: Pat Mullin (1948)
  • DH: Corey Dickerson (2017)
  • SP: Dave Stenhouse (1962)

The Anonymous All-Stars Team

There is also a group of players whose All-Star selections were surprising. Here are some examples:
  • C: Steve Swisher (1976)
  • 1B: Bryan LaHair (2012)
  • 2B: Mike Sharperson (1992)
  • 3B: Don Wert (1968)
  • SS: Billy Hunter (1953)
  • OF: Myril Hoag (1939)
  • OF: Domonic Brown (2013)
  • OF: Richie Scheinblum (1972)
  • DH: Daniel Vogelbach (2019)
  • SP: Mark Redman (2006)
  • RP: Derrick Turnbow (2006)
These stories remind us that baseball is full of surprises and that, sometimes, opportunity and circumstances can bring unexpected players to the biggest stage.
Share This Article