MLB: Expert Predictions for September and the Postseason

Deep Dive into the 2025 MLB Season: Predictions and Key Scenarios

September has arrived! With five months of the 2025 Major League Baseball season elapsed, several trends seem established, while intrigue remains in this final stretch. Alofoke Deportes presents a detailed analysis of expert projections, exploring the most relevant scenarios and the boldest predictions.

Who Will Compete for the Playoffs?

The key question is which of the current contenders will reach the postseason. How will the close divisional races unfold? Which teams will secure direct passes to the first round? To answer these questions, we consulted 16 baseball experts, who shared their perspectives and predictions.

Who Will Have the Best Record in the League?

Milwaukee Brewers: 14 votes
Detroit Tigers: 1 vote
Los Angeles Dodgers: 1 vote

The Brewers are the favorites due to their consistent performance and a solid run differential. Their favorable schedule and balanced production in all positions make them a complete team. – Bradford Doolittle
Bradford Doolittle

Which Teams Will Reach the Postseason?

All 12 projected teams: 15 votes
11 teams: 1 vote

One of the most notable predictions is the possible entry of the Kansas City Royals into the playoffs, displacing the Mariners. The Royals have shown great performance in July and August, with outstanding players like Vinnie Pasquantino and Bobby Witt Jr. The key matchup will be a home series against Seattle in mid-September.

Who Will Be the Number 1 Seed in the American League?

Detroit Tigers: 14 votes
Toronto Blue Jays: 2 votes

The Tigers’ favorable schedule gives them an advantage. In such a tight race, factors like luck in the schedule can be decisive. – Jeff Passan
Jeff Passan

Although the Tigers have had an irregular performance after the All-Star break, the Blue Jays are showing a better level, with a more powerful offensive attack and a formidable pitching staff. However, most experts favor Detroit due to their schedule.

Who Will Get the Second Direct Pass in the National League?

Los Angeles Dodgers: 9 votes
Philadelphia Phillies: 5 votes
San Diego Padres: 2 votes

Despite injuries and ups and downs, the Dodgers are favored to secure the second spot. Their bullpen and lineup are close to being complete, and their rotation is solid. The Phillies, on the other hand, are in a favorable position, with an excellent starting pitcher and key players in good form.

Who Will Win the National League West Division?

Los Angeles Dodgers: 13 votes
San Diego Padres: 3 votes

The Dodgers, with their strategic approach and injury management, are the favorites. The Padres, with a high-level roster and key players in free agency, could surprise. Pressure and different playing styles will influence the final outcome.

Who Will Win the American League West Division?

Houston Astros: 8 votes
Seattle Mariners: 8 votes

Competition in the American League West is very fierce. The Astros, with Yordan Alvarez back and more experience, are a safe bet. The Mariners, healthy and with an elite pitching rotation, could surprise. The three-game series between both teams at the end of September will be crucial.

How Many Losses Will the Rockies Accumulate?

119 losses: 1 vote
118 losses: 3 votes
117 losses: 1 vote
116 losses: 3 votes
115 losses: 3 votes
114 losses: 3 votes
113 losses: 1 vote
112 losses: 1 vote

The Rockies are expected to have a difficult September, with a demanding schedule and a young team. Most experts predict they will lose a large number of games.

Bold Predictions for the Season Finale

Cal Raleigh (Mariners) will finish the season with 60 home runs.
Shohei Ohtani will surpass Cal Raleigh in WAR.
Nick Kurtz (Athletics) will be in the top five in the American League MVP voting.
Andrew Painter will be called up by the Phillies on September 7th and will have a 3-0 record with a 1.50 ERA.
Nolan McLean will be the best pitcher in the National League (excluding Paul Skenes) and will be the Game 1 starter for the Mets in the playoffs.
Garrett Crochet (Red Sox) will win the American League Cy Young Award.
The Red Sox will surpass the Blue Jays and win the American League East Division.
The Yankees will win the American League East Division.
The Yankees will get a bye to the first round.
The Yankees will finish with the second-best record in the American League and will play against the Red Sox in the wild card round.
The Padres will win the National League West Division.
The Mets will win the National League East Division.
The playoff bracket will be identical to what would be seen if the playoffs started tomorrow.

The 2025 MLB season promises an exciting finish. Stay connected to Alofoke Deportes for more analysis and coverage.