MLB: Deep Dive into the 2025 Ranking, Hits and Misses?

Analysis of the Top 50 MLB Players in 2025: Who’s Up and Who’s Down?

To kick off the 2025 MLB season, over 60 baseball experts from Alofoke Deportes gathered to rank the top 100 players in the sport. Now, more than four months into the season, a reevaluation of the top 50 has been conducted, based on current performance and expectations for the rest of the season.

Who Is Overrated?

It’s a bit absurd that we have Nick Kurtz above Freddie Freeman, who dominated the most important event in baseball less than a year ago, or Pete Alonso, who just tied the Mets franchise home run record.
Commentator

Regarding Juan Soto, although he has hit home runs and received walks, his batting average has decreased and his defense is not the best. Furthermore, his performance in crucial situations has been poor.

Who Is Undervalued?

Are there many pitchers you’d prefer in a big game than Nathan Eovaldi? I don’t think so.
Commentator

Eovaldi has shown an impressive performance, with a low ERA and a remarkable comeback after an injury. Cristopher Sánchez has also had an outstanding performance, and his career could be on the rise.

Who Could Surprise?

Ronald Acuña Jr., despite his injuries, remains one of the most exciting players in the game. His return could change the perception of his position on the list. Brandon Woodruff could also make a significant impact once he fully recovers his velocity.

The Correct Items from the Original List

Manny Machado has had a comeback season, already surpassing his WAR from previous seasons and climbing in the rankings. Corbin Carroll remained in a position similar to that of the original list, demonstrating his consistency.

Errors in the Original List

Eovaldi, with his low effectiveness, should be higher on the current list. In addition, no relievers were included, despite their importance in key moments.