MLB 2025-26: Free Agent Analysis, Kyle Tucker and Alex Bregman

Detailed Analysis of MLB Free Agents 2025-26: Perspectives and Predictions

The MLB free agent class for the 2025-26 season presents an intriguing landscape, despite not featuring star names like Aaron Judge, Shohei Ohtani, or Juan Soto, who dominated recent markets. However, this class is rich in power hitters, closing relievers, and an interesting mix of starters and third basemen. The uncertainty about where these players will land adds excitement to the offseason, with the potential for one or two unexpected signings, such as the possible departure of Kyle Schwarber from the Phillies or Pete Alonso from the Mets, to generate significant moves. Historically, high-profile free agents have held considerable value. The top 10 agents from last season retained 82% of their value, a higher percentage than in previous seasons, suggesting smarter investment by teams. Here’s a breakdown of the most prominent prospects for the 2025-26 offseason, with an analysis of their potential destinations and projections.

Player with the Greatest Surprise Potential: Kyle Tucker

Kyle Tucker emerges as the most coveted free agent, with projections of an 11-year, $418 million contract. Despite his talent, Tucker presents certain risks. He will enter his 29-year-old season, a considerable age for contracts of this magnitude. Furthermore, he has dealt with significant injuries in recent seasons, which could influence his value. Given his high valuation, few teams can afford Tucker. The Dodgers, Mets, Yankees, Phillies, and Blue Jays, with large payrolls, could be contenders, although each faces specific challenges.

• Dodgers: With space in their budget and a need in the outfield, but with an eye on rejuvenating their roster.
• Mets: With financial capacity, but with significant financial commitments if they renew Alonso and Díaz.
• Yankees: The outfield is already saturated with talent, which could limit their interest.
• Phillies: They will prioritize renewing Schwarber, in addition to covering other needs in the team.
• Blue Jays: They could be the favorites, but a $400 million contract could be too expensive along with Guerrero Jr.’s.

If the aforementioned teams fail to secure Tucker, other teams such as the Orioles, Giants, Rangers, Reds, and White Sox could be options. Each of these teams presents its own advantages and disadvantages in the pursuit of this coveted player.

Key Player for the Dodgers: Bo Bichette

Bichette is shaping up to be the piece the Dodgers need. He could improve second base, bring a high batting average, and is at the peak of his career. With a projected five-year, $130 million contract, Bichette fits perfectly into the Dodgers’ budget, leaving room for a closer.

The Ideal Player for the Reds: Kyle Schwarber

Schwarber fits perfectly in Cincinnati, which is looking for an impact hitter. His projected contract is more affordable than Tucker’s, and his connection to Ohio could be an important factor for the Reds.

Explosive Potential or Great Disappointment: Munetaka Murakami

Murakami stands out for his power, but also for his high strikeout rate. If he manages to adapt to MLB’s speed, he could be a very valuable player. Estimates of his contract vary considerably, reflecting the risk and potential involved.

The Versatile Player: Cody Bellinger

Bellinger offers defensive versatility and good performance as a runner. His projected contract is more affordable than Tucker’s, making him an attractive option for several teams. The Tigers, Rangers, and Mets could benefit from his arrival.

The Player the Phillies Need: Alex Bregman

Bregman would bring experience and a change of attitude to the Phillies, as well as improve the offense. He could replace Bohm at third base and provide a more impactful bat at the top of the lineup.

The Risk Closer: Devin Williams

Williams could be a bargain for a team in need of a closer. Despite an uneven season, his underlying stats suggest he’s still an elite reliever. The Mariners could be a good destination for Williams.

The Best Moment to Sign: Tatsuya Imai

Imai had a great performance in Japan, and his arrival in MLB could generate a lucrative contract. However, his control and his dependence on the fastball could be a challenge in the majors.

The Player for the Pirates: Ryan O’Hearn

O’Hearn could get a chance to play daily with the Pirates, who are looking to strengthen their roster.

The Veteran Pitcher: Justin Verlander

Verlander, despite his age, remains a valuable pitcher. A one-year contract could be a good investment for a team that needs an experienced starter, like the Giants.