Emmanuel Clase: New Accusations for Manipulated Pitches and Illegal Gambling
Cleveland Guardians pitcher Emmanuel Clase is facing broader accusations than initially known, according to recent court documents. The Dominican reliever allegedly manipulated pitches in at least 48 games over a two-year period, purportedly to benefit gamblers. In the initial formal accusation, only nine matches in which Clase allegedly engaged in this practice were mentioned. However, a new filing submitted by the lawyer of Luis Ortiz, Clase’s teammate and identified as a co-conspirator, indicates that the Government now attributes a much more extensive illicit conduct to Clase.Ortiz’s lawyer, Cristos N. Georgalis, requested the court to separate the cases of both pitchers, arguing that there are clearly distinct levels of responsibility and that his client would not be able to receive a fair trial if both proceedings continue together. According to the document, Ortiz would only be implicated in two games in June 2025, while Clase would have conspired with bettors between 2023 and 2025. Georgalis argued that presenting to a jury 26 months of alleged criminal activity attributed to Clase, including suspicious pitches in dozens of games, frequent communications with gamblers, money transfers, and coordination of illegal bets, could negatively influence Ortiz’s case. Class participated in 197 regular season games between 2023 and July 2025, when MLB placed him on non-disciplinary administrative leave amid the investigation into betting. If the accusations are confirmed, the pitcher would have manipulated his performance in approximately a quarter of those encounters. An additional court document reveals that a judge requested the Government to provide Clase’s defense with the evidence related to the pitches considered suspicious. The player has identified at least 250 pitches on which bets were placed, so the court urged the prosecutors to disclose any additional evidence included in the alleged conspiracy. Both Clase and Ortiz pleaded not guilty to charges of conspiracy to commit wire fraud, honest services fraud, money laundering, and conspiracy to influence sporting events through bribery. The most serious charges carry penalties of up to 20 years in prison. According to prosecutors, both pitchers allegedly received thousands of dollars in bribes to help two unidentified bettors, residents of the Dominican Republic, make profits of at least US$460,000, betting on the outcome and speed of certain pitches. Class, a three-time All-Star and two-time American League Reliever of the Year, was in the fourth year of a five-season, US$20 million contract. Ortiz, for his part, played three seasons with the Pittsburgh Pirates before joining Cleveland in 2025, where he participated in 16 games. Both remain on administrative leave. The trial is scheduled to begin on May 4, although Ortiz’s defense has requested more time to prepare the case.Ortiz’s lawyer requested the court that the cases of both pitchers be separated, arguing that there are clearly distinct levels of responsibility.
Cristos N. Georgalis
