TMO in the spotlight after failure: Are Dan Sheehan and Lynagh, controversy in rugby?

The rugby world is in turmoil after a weekend full of action and controversy. Australia’s victory over the British and Irish Lions by 22-12 in the third test not only meant the Lions’ defeat, but also unleashed a debate about refereeing decisions and controversial plays.

Controversy in the Field

After Jac Morgan’s action was deemed legal, player Dan Sheehan was cited by World Rugby’s independent officer, Adrien Menez, on Sunday morning. The play in question has generated controversy and has put the work of match officials in the public eye. The match was marked by a 38-minute interruption due to an electrical storm, which could have affected the course of the game. Despite this, Australia knew how to take advantage of the situation and secure the victory at Accor Stadium. Australia’s satisfaction increased after Tom Lynagh’s injury, who suffered a head injury after a play by Sheehan. Wallabies coach Joe Schmidt praised Lynagh’s bravery, but chose not to comment on Sheehan’s play.

Sheehan’s play, which impacted Lynagh, was apparently overlooked by the Television Match Official, Marius Jonker, generating criticism. The replay of the play spread rapidly on social media, evidencing Sheehan’s impact on Lynagh. Lynagh had to leave the field for a concussion assessment and did not return to the game.

Schmidt commented that he hadn’t had the opportunity to review the play in detail, but that they would focus on taking care of Lynagh and ensuring his recovery. Jonker intervened in other less relevant situations, which generated confusion among the players, the fans, and the referee. Lions coach Andy Farrell said he hadn’t seen the replay of Sheehan’s play and emphasized that there are many incidents in rugby that can be analyzed. The hearing regarding Sheehan’s citation will take place on Sunday, following the World Rugby off-field sanctioning process.